Green Day

guitarbabe · Post by **guitarbabe** » Tue Aug 08, 2006 1:52 pm

I'll listen to some Metallica

or maybe Venom *snarls*

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA · Post by **NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA** » Tue Aug 08, 2006 1:54 pm

painkiller182 · Post by **painkiller182** » Tue Aug 08, 2006 2:22 pm

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote:the offspring are pop - punk....not TRUE PUNK

The Offspring are most certainly punk. Pop punk is also a very a disputable term. The Ramones and Buzzcocks could easily be considered "Pop-Punk". Their sound is rooted in catchy melodies, and bubblegum pop. Yet you cannot find a truer distillation of punk music than The Ramones. The Offspring, along with their comtemporaries Green Day, and Rancid are rooted in these pop-punk influences and their sound also fits the criteria of being punk as well. So therefore they are punk, despite being called "pop-punk". More commercial maybe.....but their pop-punk sound is not really a departure from The Ramones....which is True Punk.

rachel-k wrote:yeah political but sucked. most brittish punk do... ugh johnny rotten..

Really?....I figured Sid Vicious would be the Sex Pistol to be more likely to be hated.

Anyways, I think Johnny Rotten is alright. Sid Vicious is untalented...

guitarbabe · Post by **guitarbabe** » Tue Aug 08, 2006 2:34 pm

painkiller182 wrote:The Offspring are most certainly punk. Pop punk is also a very a disputable term. The Ramones and Buzzcocks could easily be considered "Pop-Punk". Their sound is rooted in catchy melodies, and bubblegum pop. Yet you cannot find a truer distillation of punk music than The Ramones. The Offspring, along with their comtemporaries Green Day, and Rancid are rooted in these pop-punk influences and their sound also fits the criteria of being punk as well. So therefore they are punk, despite being called "pop-punk". More commercial maybe.....but their pop-punk sound is not really a departure from The Ramones....which is True Punk.

yeah 8)

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA · Post by **NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA** » Tue Aug 08, 2006 4:22 pm

whatever i'm not in a mood to argue but whatever.

Gitza · Post by **Gitza** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 2:25 am

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote:the offspring are pop - punk....not TRUE PUNK

wtf!? Learn how to fly !..

You don`t know nothing , and call yourself a man who knows a music(or whatever).. ?.. Fuck..
World is full of stupid ppls..
Sorry it`s not my intention to give umbrage to u(or whatever) , but the true is you don`t know the shit about offspring..

missgrunge · Post by **missgrunge** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 2:37 am

i remember my brother listened to offspring when it was in.
however offspring is very good band,but i'm not a fan of it.

greenday:
it has two sides:

1.gd is cool cauze they share with the world a punk culture and now there is so much punker and people who knows what is punk ... listening a songs like american idiot and etc. or someone says oooo let's explore what is punk.And really became a punker.(discovering old punk bands)

2.gd sells punk like some sh*t.
they lebel ourselfes like PUNK.
And punk is not mainstream.
It never was it.good charlotte is not a punk.
for goodness sake PUNK MEANS SO MUCH.
and now it is just 'greeny dayy'

However.I don't have a strong opinion about gd.
fu*k it...

Gitza · Post by **Gitza** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 2:40 am

When someone don`t have any respect for some great band or don`t have any knowledge about something and notwithstanding he spell shits , but actually don`t know nothing , I can`t calm down.. fuck..

guitarbabe · Post by **guitarbabe** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 7:59 am

the offspring are so kickass 8)

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA · Post by **NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 10:23 am

Gitza wrote:
NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote:the offspring are pop - punk....not TRUE PUNK
wtf!? Learn how to fly !..

You don`t know nothing , and call yourself a man who knows a music(or whatever).. ?.. Fuck..
World is full of stupid ppls..
Sorry it`s not my intention to give umbrage to u(or whatever) , but the true is you don`t know the shit about offspring..

believe me i know plenty about the offspring, in my circle of friends they're well known lets just say. lemme say smash is a very good album americana too, but isn't punk supposed to be non-comercial? maybe its the fingers talkin but at least they haven't gone the way of green day.

Gitza · Post by **Gitza** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 12:12 pm

guitarbabe wrote:the offspring are so kickass 8)

8)

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote: but isn't punk supposed to be non-comercial?

Who`s saying?.. (x..

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote: maybe its the fingers talkin but at least they haven't gone the way of green day

yeah..

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA · Post by **NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 2:40 pm

well green day DID get kicked out of the punk rock circle for getting huge. its easy to make songs that are non comercial but can still please your audience. that's what pearl jam did for a few years right?

painkiller182 · Post by **painkiller182** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 7:42 pm

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA wrote:well green day DID get kicked out of the punk rock circle for getting huge. its easy to make songs that are non comercial but can still please your audience. that's what pearl jam did for a few years right?

sorry if i came across as a douche to you in my previous argument. I have a habit of running my mouth like that, so I apologize for that.

NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA · Post by **NIRVANA NIRVANA NIRVANA** » Thu Aug 10, 2006 10:59 am

i don't care it's fine i deal with all the time, i'm not easily offended anymore.

guitarbabe · Post by **guitarbabe** » Thu Aug 10, 2006 11:13 am

cuz it's the internet, it's the internet man!!!